Saturday, September 14, 2013

If an Insured Disputes The Carrier's Repair Recommendations, Can The Carrier Issue a Notice of Nonrenewal?

Last week I discussed the carrier's obligation to fully investigate a reported loss.  This week, I want to discuss an interesting issue that arises during sinkhole losses related to the insured's duty to mitigate.  In the event of a sinkhole loss, the insured has an obligation to enter into a subsurface repair contract to remediate the property.  Some carriers wrongfully issue a Notice of Nonrenewal if the insured does not immediately enter such a contract.  The issue that I want to discuss is whether an insured is failing to mitigate his or her damages when contesting the carrier's repair recommendations.